Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tamara's avatar

What I read in your essay has a precise philosophical antecedent that rarely gets cited unfortunately. Jung called it “enantiodromia” = the principle that anything pushed to its extreme converts into its opposite. A culture that relentlessly exteriorises masculine energy and buries the feminine in its men produces brittleness. And brittleness, when threatened, becomes cruelty obviously.

The violence problem is, at its root, an integration problem.

Your horse-stable education is more instructive than most gender theory syllabi because horses operate on the nervous system directly. They respond to incongruence. You cannot project confidence while feeling fear; they know. That involuntary calibration between inner state and outer expression is precisely what gets educated out of both boys and girls through gendered socialisation. Boys learn to perform dominance they don’t feel; girls learn to perform softness they don’t always want. The performance is there. The gap between the performance and the actual life force widens. And the gap, I’d argue, is where violence breeds.

I noticed your observation that you “did not move like girl victim”, and this is a quality of presence that communicates full inhabitation of one’s own body. It sounds like completeness to me.

Predatory behaviour is, in many documented cases, precisely calibrated to find incompleteness, the dissociation, the trained deference, the over-managed affect. Which means the conversation about safety cannot be reduced to legal frameworks or even cultural norms alone. It has to go into the body.

The deepest thing you’ve written here is almost a throwaway line: “the source is one”. So poetic. I love it! It’s the thing that both the gender warriors and their opponents keep missing. The binary describes a wound we collectively decided to call a social structure.

The generation you’re writing for will need this as practice.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

I am honoured you read me, Karin! I also have to learn a lot from you. Thank you!

Kim Williams, M.Div.'s avatar

Much of my thoughts have already been said here in the comments. I'll share two things: 1. This is an issue long in the making. It is a significant distortion of our true nature. 2. Here is an excellent article that I think overlays some of your points beautifully: https://leftbrainmystic.substack.com/p/the-most-harmful-spiritual-myth-gendered?r=3ghjr&utm_medium=ios

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?